Bruce Springsteen and Jon Bon Jovi: Comparing Solo Albums and Styles

Bruce Springsteen and Jon Bon Jovi are synonymous with their respective bands: The E Street Band and Bon Jovi.

These groups defined not just their careers but entire eras of rock music.

However, both legends ventured into solo projects—Springsteen with Lucky Town* and Human Touch* in 1992, and Bon Jovi with Young Guns II: Blaze of Glory* and Destination Anywhere* in 1990 and 1997, respectively.

Each artist’s solo journey was a risk, stepping away from the camaraderie and sound that had made them global superstars.

This post explores their creative motivations, the critical and commercial outcomes of their solo work, and how these projects impacted their relationships with fans and bands.

The Backstory: Why Go Solo?

Bruce Springsteen: Navigating Change

By the late 1980s, Bruce Springsteen was in transition.

After the monumental success of Born in the U.S.A., he disbanded The E Street Band in 1989, a move that shocked fans.

Springsteen later said he needed to explore new artistic directions without the weight of band expectations.

In 1992, he released Human Touch and Lucky Town simultaneously, each showcasing a different facet of his songwriting.

These albums marked his first major works without The E Street Band, relying instead on session musicians. It was a bold move that divided fans and critics.

Jon Bon Jovi: From Cowboy to Storyteller

For Jon Bon Jovi, the desire to go solo came from a slightly different place. Following Bon Jovi’s success in the 1980s, Jon was drawn to film soundtracks.

Young Guns II: Blaze of Glory (1990) was his first solo project, a concept album inspired by the Western aesthetic of the movie.

Later, Destination Anywhere (1997) reflected his growth as a songwriter, embracing more introspective themes and experimental sounds.

While the band wasn’t officially disbanded, Jon used these projects to explore his identity outside the group.

Bon Jovi’s Keep the Faith was a surprising comeback in practically the middle of the grunge period of rock n’ roll. Its follow-up These Days also sold well.

Oh, and in between? A little iconic ballad called “Always.” All while many felt one of the faces of 80’s hard rock and hair metal time had passed.

Critics! Thank God they don’t buy albums.

The Albums: Comparing Sound and Themes

Springsteen’s Human Touch and Lucky Town

• Human Touch: This album was polished and radio-friendly, leaning into themes of love and redemption. Songs like “Human Touch” and “57 Channels (And Nothin’ On)” explored personal connections but were criticized for lacking the grit of his earlier work.

Stream Human Touch on Spotify.

• Lucky Town: More spontaneous and introspective, Lucky Town featured tracks like “Better Days” and “Living Proof,” capturing a rawer side of Springsteen. It was written and recorded quickly, giving it an organic feel compared to the more labored production of Human Touch.

Stream Lucky Town on Spotify.

Despite some standout tracks, both albums faced some criticism for feeling disconnected from Springsteen’s working-class roots.

But there wasa bright side – a great performance that may have flown under the radar over time – MTV Plugged.

But more on that in another post. CLICK HERE.

Bon Jovi’s Blaze of Glory and Destination Anywhere

• Blaze of Glory: Rooted in the Young Guns II soundtrack, this album was a concept-driven exploration of outlaw themes. Tracks like “Blaze of Glory” and “Miracle” showcased Jon’s ability to tell cinematic stories, earning him a Golden Globe and an Oscar nomination.

Stream Blaze of Glory on Spotify.

• Destination Anywhere: A stylistic departure, this album blended rock, pop, and alternative influences. Songs like “Midnight in Chelsea” and “Ugly” revealed a more vulnerable side of Jon, reflecting on fame, relationships, and personal struggles.

Stream Destination Anywhere on Spotify.

Both projects allowed Bon Jovi to stretch creatively, though Destination Anywhere was less commercially successful than Blaze of Glory.

Successes and Failures: Critical and Commercial Reception

Springsteen’s Wins and Challenges

Lucky Town was praised for its sincerity, while Human Touch saw strong sales, reaching multi-platinum status. Tracks like “Human Touch” and “If I Should Fall Behind” have become fan favorites over time.

Critics felt the absence of The E Street Band. The slick production of Human Touch alienated fans who longed for the raw emotion of Nebraska or Born to Run.

Jon Bon Jovi’s Wins and Challenges

Blaze of Glory was a critical triumph, cementing Jon’s ability to succeed outside the band. The title track remains a staple of his solo repertoire.

Destination Anywhere failed to match the commercial success of previous Bon Jovi albums, though it earned respect for its artistic risks.

Fan Reactions: Divided Loyalties

Springsteen’s Fans

Many die-hard Springsteen fans felt betrayed by the absence of The E Street Band, who were integral to his sound. While some appreciated the solo experimentation, others saw it as a misstep.

Jon Bon Jovi’s Fans

Jon’s fans were generally more forgiving, perhaps because his band wasn’t officially disbanded. Still, Destination Anywhere’s experimental tone puzzled some fans used to Bon Jovi’s anthemic rock.

Touring Without the Band

Springsteen toured extensively to support Human Touch and Lucky Town, using session musicians like Shayne Fontayne. While the performances were solid, they lacked the chemistry and magic of The E Street Band.

Jon’s 1997 solo tour was more intimate, showcasing his storytelling and connection with the audience. He also previously toured with Southside Johnny as a guitarist, which further emphasized his Jersey roots, even as he started to experiemnt with new sounds.

Acting Ventures: Jon Bon Jovi’s Hollywood Moment

Jon’s foray into acting during the 1990s added another layer to his solo identity. From starring in Moonlight and Valentino to guest appearances in Ally McBeal, he proved himself as a multi-talented artist.

While his acting career didn’t reach the heights of his music, it helped keep his name in the spotlight during the band’s hiatus.

The Reunions: Coming Home

Springsteen and The E Street Band

By 1999, Springsteen reunited with The E Street Band for the Reunion Tour, which was met with overwhelming enthusiasm. Albums like The Rising cemented their legacy, proving the band was stronger together.

Jon Bon Jovi and the Band

Bon Jovi’s reunion was less dramatic, as the band never officially split.

Taking another hiatus after a worldwide These Days tour, they returned with Crush in 2000, which spawned the biggest rock song of 2000 – “It’s My Life” – and marked a successful new chapter.

Legacy and Impact

Both Springsteen and Bon Jovi’s solo ventures showcased their artistic range but also highlighted the undeniable chemistry of their bands.

For fans, these projects offered a view into the artists’ personal and creative evolution, even if they didn’t always resonate as deeply as their original band work.

Conclusion: Risks Worth Taking

Going solo is a leap of faith, especially for artists so closely tied to iconic bands.

While Springsteen and Jon Bon Jovi’s solo projects were met with mixed reactions, they proved these legends’ willingness to challenge themselves creatively.

Ultimately, their reunions reinforced the power of band collaboration (in the studio and on stage), solidifying their legacies as bandleaders.

Sources:

1. Marsh, Dave. Glory Days: Bruce Springsteen in the 1980s. Pantheon Books, 1987.

2. Masciotra, David. Working on a Dream: The Progressive Political Vision of Bruce Springsteen. Bloomsbury Academic, 2010.

3. Bon Jovi, Jon. When We Were Beautiful. HarperCollins, 2010.

4. Symynkywicz, Jeffrey B. The Gospel According to Bruce Springsteen. Westminster John Knox Press, 2008.

*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

**Featured image is AI generated